Alex Finlay’s The Anniversary is a razor-sharp, high-concept thriller built around a single date that refuses to let go: May 1, 1992. In one violent night, two teenagers from opposite sides of a quiet Midwestern town are set on irreversible paths. Jules Delaney, the school’s "golden girl," narrowly survives a brush with the elusive May Day Killer, while Quinn Riley, a social outsider, is arrested after a birthday brawl spirals into a near-fatal incident. From there, Finlay revisits their lives exclusively on May 1st, year after year, tracking the echoes of that night as they ripple through the decades.
That chronological structure is the novel’s primary hook—and its greatest strength. Each chapter drops the reader into a new year without hand-holding, forcing you to piece together what has changed, what’s been lost, and what still lingers in the gaps between anniversaries. The result is a narrative that feels lean and fast, yet quietly immersive, skipping the filler of a traditional epic to focus on the moments that truly define a life.
The emotional core of the book is anchored by how differently the two protagonists carry their scars. Jules’s is haunted by survivor’s guilt and the chilling reality that her attacker strikes like clockwork every spring. Quinn, upon his release from juvenile detention, discovers his mother was murdered during his absence—a case the authorities were all too happy to let go cold. Their stories run in parallel, occasionally colliding and bound by a shared trauma that neither fully understands.
As the years stack up, so does the tension. The May Day Killer remains active, the past refuses to stay buried, and the connection between Jules’s assault and Quinn’s loss shifts from coincidence toward a sense of grim inevitability. The Anniversary is a superb read that propels the reader on the same intersecting path as Jules and Quinn toward a dynamic conclusion of the book and to their emotional torture. Finlay doesn't just construct a mystery; he maps how a single moment can fracture a life, then follows the cracks as they spread. It’s a thriller with genuine weight, and the ending lands with visceral impact. I highly recommend it!
Follow Steve on Twitter or Instagram or contact him via the site.
Purchase The Anniversary
(Note: most indie bookstores can fulfill an order as quickly as larger retailers. Please consider contacting them for your next purchase.)
Barrington Books
Chapter 2 Books
Murder By The Book
Once Upon A Crime
The Book Dragon
The Poisoned Pen
